An inclusive, Christ-centered community making a difference.


Due to unfavorable weather conditions, the Churchwide Carnival will be rescheduled to NEXT WEEKEND! Please join us on June 11 from 11 am-1 pm for food, fun, and fellowship! 

ChurchwideCarnival Small

Dreamscape [dreem-skeyp] (n.) – A vision for who God is calling us to be. 

On June 25, you voted to accept the DREAMSCAPE plan and bring a new vision for Asbury First to life. A total of 159 members participated in this in-person vote, and an overwhelming 154 individuals voted to accept the plan (that's 97%)! In our unofficial online poll, an astounding 89% voted "yes," too! From our all-new mission statement to growing our outreach programs to increasing the size and impact of our community, learn all about the DREAMSCAPE plan below and see what's coming Asbury First in the days, months, and years to come.

A Time to Dream

In 2020, Asbury First United Methodist Church will celebrate its bicentennial, marking two hundred years of faithful service to God and neighbor. None of us were here for the beginning and, by God’s grace, none of us will be here for the end. We are so grateful for the legacy of those who have gone before, and we choose today to accept our part in the story, making a way for those who come after. Our prayer is that our decisions will ensure a solid foundation for Asbury First as we embark on the next two hundred years and beyond. We walk humbly and tread lightly, but recognize the gift of this moment—to celebrate our past, assess our present, and plan for our future. In short, this is a moment to dream about who we are and who God is calling us to be. This Dreamscape—formed through the dreams of this community—is an attempt to do just that. 

“Keep alive the dream, for as long as we have a dream in our hearts, we cannot lose the significance of living.” – Howard Thurman 


Watch the Presentation and Read the Report Below 

(See the PDF version of the report here)


The Beginning of a Dream

The planning process for Asbury First’s Dreamscape began in the fall of 2015, shortly into the tenure of our new Senior Minister, the Rev. Dr. Stephen Cady. In a series of sermons on dreaming, he reminded us that we dream in communitywith humility, and for a specific time and place. It is this concept that formed the basis for this Dreamscape. 

That same fall, we placed a “dream board” in the Gathering Center and invited the entire community to share its dreams for Asbury First by writing them on the board. Children and adults alike contributed hundreds of dreams for the future of Asbury First—no dream was too silly or too big. It was a concept we had used that summer at the Park Avenue Festival and at the 2015 Tent Week to solicit dreams from our Greater Rochester community. 

While the “dream board” was up that fall, we hosted a series of town hall meetings and conversations with various leadership groups throughout the church asking the same five questions: 

1. What is Asbury First known for? 

2. What does Asbury First do better than most? 

3. What are our growing edges? 

4. What are the most important things we do? 

5. If we picked up a newspaper in ten years (assuming there are still newspapers in ten years) and read a headline about Asbury First, what would we hope it said? 

As we read the over 400 dreams from the board and heard the responses of various groups throughout the church, a dreamscape—a picture of both who we are and who we long to be as a people of faith—started to emerge. 

During the season of Lent in the winter of 2016, while the congregation prayed about who God is calling us to be, we took down the dream board and transferred every dream (the silly and the serious) to notecards. During the season of Easter, a season ripe with the promise of new life, we placed all notecards onto an “affinity board” with the goal of finding common themes among the dreams. Our community was asked to find dreams that belonged together and move them near one another, as well as to put stars on the dreams believed to be most important. Over the next few weeks, we estimate there were over 10,000 moves. As the affinity groups emerged and were labeled by the community—with themes like outreach, diversity, inclusivity, and small groups—the emerging Dreamscape became even clearer. Then—as Joseph did for the Pharaoh—we needed people to prayerfully interpret our dreams. Enter the “Dream Team.” 

Saddling our Dreams – the Work of the Dream Team

“Saddle your dreams before your ride them.” -Mary Webb 


Location: Rochester, NY 

Footprint: Our campus includes three buildings, one of which (1040) is fully accessible and two of which are not (1010 and 1050) 

Membership: 2,326 (1,290 Family units) 

Worship Services: Three traditional services (8:30, 10:00, and 11:00) 8:30 and 11:00 take place in the sanctuary, and 10:00 takes place in the chancel and includes weekly communion 

Average Weekly Worship Attendance: 702 

Annual Operating Plan: ~$2 Million 

Annual Giving: 487 family units pledge just over $1M 

Endowment: ~$8m 

Total Staff: 38 staff (3 appointed clergy, 13 full time, 25 part time/contract) 

Weekly Volunteers: 233 

Weekly Children Engagement: 115 

Weekly Youth Engagement: 45 

In June of 2016, with the blessing of the Church Council, a strategic planning team, appropriately dubbed the “Dream Team” began work on the Asbury First Dreamscape. Stephen called together a group of twelve individuals of differing opinions, backgrounds, and tenures at Asbury First in order to make sense of our dreams. 

As the Dream Team culled through the hundreds of dreams, the thousands of moves from the affinity board, and pages of notes from community conversations, they were pleased to discover Asbury First is in a healthy place as a congregation. People are generally happy, the church is growing in attendance year to year (albeit slowly), and there is a great deal of optimism as we look forward. For as much enthusiasm as there is about our congregation, however, there are clear areas—outreach, connection, inclusion, and growth—where we can do more to reach people inside and outside our congregation. 

1. Outreach 

No one reading the dreams of our community or hearing the conversations of our members could doubt that outreach is a cornerstone of Asbury First’s identity. For at least fifty years (starting with the establishment of the Storehouse), Asbury First has demonstrated a lasting commitment to outreach both on and off our campus. It has accomplished this through congregation-led and -developed ministries, as well as through strategic partnerships. The dreams of our community affirm the hard work that has gone into outreach, but challenge us to go deeper—not just to feed the hungry, clothe the naked, and heal the sick, but to figure out why people are hungry, naked, and ill. In other words, we clearly want to extend beyond mercy and compassion to justice. Fortunately for the Dream Team, a separate Outreach Task Force worked for over a year to detail a plan called, “A Way Forward,” which was approved by Church Council in December of 2016. This plan translated the dreams of Asbury First for outreach into a strategy for change. The Dreamscape acknowledges and affirms that work by recommending the full implementation of “A Way Forward” as the goal for outreach. 



Dining and Caring Center (~35k meals annually) 

The Storehouse (~6000 families served annually) 

Rochester Area Interfaith Hospitality Network (RAIHN) 

UR Well clinic 

Grocery Bag Ministry 


School 41 

West Ave Youth Café 

Habitat for Humanity 

Beyond our borders: 

Project Chacocente 

Miracle Garden  

2. Connection 

Many feel very connected to Asbury First, in particular through our worship services. People expressed a connection to the music, the preaching, and the tradition of the service. Similarly, there are many examples of deep connection outside of the worship experience. Perhaps the greatest of these connections are our long-term adult Sunday school classes (the Doublers, Fifty-Plus Fellowship, Growing Spirits/Living Edge, and the Partnership classes), some of who have been meeting together and supporting one another for over sixty years. They stand as tangible reminders of what Christian life together can and should be. Similarly, our children and youth ministries have long-established and well-respected legacies of faithful engagement in Christian community. 

While we offer several ongoing and short-term small group opportunities (some educational and some support- or fellowship-oriented), many dream of a community where there is a place for all who want one outside of worship, regardless of age or circumstance. 

3. Inclusion 

Our community of dreamers believed inclusion should be celebrated and we should continue to emphasize that all are welcome at Asbury First. Several dreamers lauded and expressed a desire to maintain our inclusive stance toward the LGBTQ+ community (Asbury First voted to adopt “Reconciling Statement” in 2015) and to push for change within the United Methodist denomination towards greater inclusion. On a similar note, while we have great diversity of thought, ideology, and age, we lack in racial and ethnic diversity, being a predominantly white congregation. Many dreamers advocate for our Asbury First community and staff to reflect better the rich diversity of the Greater Rochester community. Finally, several dreamers mourn the inaccessibility of two of our buildings to those with handicapping conditions. 

4. Growth 

Good things are meant to be shared, and we want to share the life we have found at Asbury First. Growth is a common theme in almost every area of our life together. We want to grow in our faith, grow in our relationships with one another, grow in our outreach to the community, grow in our financial stability and resources as a congregation, and grow in our attendance. We believe that growing in these areas will help us grow in our love of God and neighbor. 


Having reviewed the dream data and identified the central themes, the Dream Team—in conversation with church leadership—has attempted to clarify Asbury First’s mission, describe our core values, and articulate a vision for our future with strategic goals to help bring our dreams to life. The dreams are not just those of the team, but those of all of us—the entire Asbury First community. 

Over the winter and spring of 2017, the Dream Team presented an initial draft of this Dreamscape with the following: 

● Church Council 

● Trustees 

● SPRC (Staff Parish Relations Committee) 

● Worship & the Arts Committee 

● Asbury First Ministers & Staff 

● Technology Committee 

● Stewardship Committee 

● Communications Committee 

● Doublers Sunday School Class 

● Parables of Parenting Sunday School Class 

● 50+ Fellowship Sunday School Class 

● Growing Spirits/Living Edge Sunday School Class 

● Sunday Morning Bible Study 

● Children & Youth programming areas 

● Planned Giving Committee 

● Outreach Committee 

● Investment Committee 

Each group was asked to provide feedback, as well as to commit to developing action plans for the goals relating to their area. These groups offered helpful insight, which both affirmed the direction of the team and clarified this final report. 

The Dreamscape that follows is offered to the community of Asbury First by the community of Asbury First. It was assembled by the Dream Team but came from all of us. It represents two years of listening, praying, and dreaming together about who we are and who God is calling us to be. Thank you for taking this journey with us.  


(i.e. “What are we trying to accomplish?”) 

Jesus said, “I came that they may have life and have it abundantly.” (John 10:10b) 

Just as the Christian faith is about bringing life to the world, Asbury First is about bringing life to this community. We believe the only way to the fullness of life promised by Jesus Christ is through love—love of God and love of neighbor. Through love we find life. In a love-filled life, we are led to serve others. Through service to others, we find love fully expressed. This cycle is the heart of discipleship and as such, we believe it is the key to living into God’s dream for this community. Thus, our mission at Asbury First is to love God and neighbor, to live fully, to serve all, and then to do it all again. Or said simply—love. live. serve. repeat


Love God and neighbor. 

Live fully. 

Serve all. 



Love. Live. Serve. Repeat. 


(i.e. “What is important to us?”) 

Asbury First’s values represent a description of our guiding principles. These statements are standards of behavior, which are inherent in all we do. We value: 

Being Open to All— We believe we are all equal in God’s eyes and all are one in Christ. We extend hospitality and encourage full participation for all regardless of any perceived defining characteristic. 

Worship— We believe we are at our best when we connect to God together through preaching, prayer, and song. We strive for excellence in all we do, especially in our worship experience. 

Community— We believe we are better together; fellowship and care are keys to love and life. 

Outreach— We believe everyone deserves hope and fullness of life. We endeavor to practice mercy and work for justice in our local and extended community. 

Discipleship— We believe we—adults, youth, and children alike—are called to grow in our faith both as a community and individuals through education, regular worship, meaningful fellowship, a commitment to service, and celebrating rites of passage together. 

Generosity— We believe what we have is a gift from God. We share our gifts with an open heart to help meet needs at Asbury First, the Rochester community, and throughout the world. 

Stewardship— We believe we must care for the human, physical, and financial resources with which we have been entrusted. 


(i.e. “Where do we go from here?”) 

Do all the good you can, 
By all the means you can, 
In all the ways you can, 
In all the places you can, 
At all the times you can, 
To all the people you can, 
As long as you ever can. 

~A Wesleyan Rule for Life 

The calling of the Christian faith—a calling to the fullness of life expressed in Jesus Christ—has never changed. For twenty centuries, Christians have attempted to live into that calling of love with varying degrees of success. For nearly two centuries, the people of Asbury First have endeavored to do the same, making it our perennial mission to love God and neighbor, to live fully, and to serve all. While we have never been perfect, with God’s grace we have experienced great successes along the way. More than anything else, our dreams reveal the heart of this community—a heart that breaks for the least, the last, and the lost of this world and longs to make a greater difference. We have always cared for each other and the community around us, but we long to do more. As we look toward the next two centuries, our hope is to build upon the good work already being done, to deepen our life together, and to have a greater impact on this community and beyond. Our vision for the future, therefore, does not take us in a radically new direction, but rather asks us to do more good. 


Do More Good. 


(i.e. “How will we know when we’re there?”) 

Our mission, values, and vision were identified from our shared dreams but also provided the platform upon which our dreams were clarified. Once the framework was set through the hard work done on the mission, values, and vision, the Dream Team re-examined the dream data to suggest our missional goals for the years ahead. We articulate these goals under the banner of our core values and express them below as future states—as if we have already done more good in each of these areas. 

Each goal has a number, a title, a concise description of the desired state, and an assignment of responsibility. An asterisk (*) indicates those areas for which we believe additional resources (human, structural, or financial) may be required. 

1.0 Being OPEN TO ALL 

● 1.1. Accessibility: Our buildings are fully accessible to those with physical needs for all areas used in church activities. 


● 1.2. Diversity: Our church in word, practice, and worship is reflective of a diverse set of cultures and perspectives. Our congregation, staff, and lay leadership reflect our Greater Rochester community. 

Responsibility—Church Council, SPRC, Hospitality, New Task Force/Committee* 

● 1.3. Hospitality: All who enter Asbury First for any reason (whether worship, programmatic activity, or spiritual or other need) encounter a unique sense of warmth and welcome within our community. 

Responsibility—Hospitality, Staff, Leadership 


● 2.1. Attendance: Our weekly worship attendance is at 1,000, an increase of approximately fifty percent from 2017. 

Responsibility—Worship and the Arts, Communication Team, Hospitality 

● 2.2. Technology: Our worship experience is faithfully expanded through digital media. 

Responsibility—Technology, Worship and Arts, Communication Team 


● 3.1. Connection: All who desire one have a place within the Asbury First community beyond worship. 

Responsibility—Discipleship, Communication Team, Church Council, Volunteer Coordinator* 

● 3.2. Care: People within our Asbury First community receive the right care at the right time in the right place. 

Responsibility—Staff, Congregational Care 

● 3.3 Communication: Information is communicated effectively to all audiences inside and outside our community. 

Responsibility—Communication Team*, Church Council, Staff, Technology 


● 4.1. Strategy Alignment: The Outreach Taskforce report, “A Way Forward” has been faithfully implemented. 

Responsibility—Outreach, Church Council, SPRC, Pastors 


● 5.1. Faith Development: A clear pathway for discipleship is available for all in our community. 

Responsibility—Discipleship, Pastors 

● 5.2. Celebration: We grow our faith through the celebration of life’s rites of passage together. 

Responsibility—Discipleship, Staff, Communication Team 


● 6.1. Time: All members of our community volunteer in some way (either within our Asbury First community or outside our community). 

Responsibility—Leadership, Volunteer Coordinator*, Technology 

● 6.2. Talent: All members of our community are able to use their talents and leadership abilities within our community to serve others. 

Responsibility—Nominations, Volunteer Coordinator*, Program Staff 

● 6.3. Treasure: All members of our community give financially (and pledge) to Asbury First as they are able with many members tithing. 

Responsibility—Stewardship, Planned Giving 


● 7.1. Endowment: Our endowment is currently at $10M. 

Responsibility—Trustees, Planned Giving 

● 7.2. Capital Improvements: A 15-year revolving plan and process is in place to manage capital improvements. 


● 7.3. Structure and Systems: Our structure and systems are organized in a missionally effective way. 

Responsibility—Church Council, Leadership, Technology, SPRC 

Living the Dream – an Implementation Plan

If we accept this Dreamscape, the mission, vision, and values of Asbury First will be officially updated. All church materials will be updated, and unique communication strategies will be created to explain this work for future Asbury First visitors and members. 

This plan will be integrated into our existing committee structure. The Church Council will assume the leadership for and ownership of this plan, and ensure responsible parties (indicated within the goals themselves) at Asbury First are able to achieve their respective goal. 

All responsible parties will develop action plans—possibly spanning several years—to bring these dreams to life. These action plans will include current state evaluations with projected targets for set increments of time. Church Council will then hold each responsible party accountable to their plans and the achievement of their goals. New data recording and reporting mechanisms will be developed, and annual committee, volunteer, and staff reports will reflect progress on these goals. 

The Dreamscape will be a guiding beacon as we navigate the unknown future. It will become the ruler by which we measure decisions and how we know if we have been successful in loving God and neighbor, living fully, and serving all. Our prayer is that, by God’s grace, this Dreamscape will permeate all layers of our community, embolden us to do more good, and provide a foundation for the next 200 years of faithful ministry at Asbury First. 

Next Steps

QUESTIONS: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. 


Town Hall Meetings 

Sunday 6/4 – 9am in Fellowship Hall 

Sunday 6/18 – 9am in Fellowship Hall 

Wednesday 6/14 – 6:30pm in Gathering Center 

ACTION: Vote on Sunday 6/25 

AFTER: Another 200 years begins! 

Summer Celebration xsOur summer worship schedule will last from Memorial Day weekend to Labor Day weekend (inclusive)! Join us for both indoor and outdoor services all summer long.

These summer service times are as follows:

8:30 am — Outside worship with Holy Communion

10 am — Traditional worship inside the sanctuary

Join Asbury First During Holy Week! 

EasterCrosses Small

Childcare is available at all services marked with an asterisk*



6:30 pm*
Sanctuary open for silent meditation

7 pm*
Living tableaus of scenes from the life of Christ

7:30 pm*
Worship, Holy Communion, and a reenactment of the passion of Christ



6 am
Informal service of Holy Communion

12 pm*
Worship and reflection on art and music (music provided by Voices Chamber Choir)

6-7:30 pm
Family Prayer Night: An open house with activities that draw us closer to God and our faith, such as Holy Communion and walking the labyrinth (All are welcome)



8:30 am*
Traditional worship

10 am*
Brief service of Holy Communion (no sermon)

11 am*
Traditional worship     

yoga coupleSundays, March 5-April 9 from 6:30-7:30 pm in the Gathering Center

This is a yoga class for people of all experience levels and abilities. Classes will be taught by Lynn Boucher, Nazareth College’s “yoga chaplain,” and will integrate spiritual themes, meditation, and self-reflection. Asbury First’s theme for Lent is the search for common ground, and yoga invites us to reflect on the literal ground that supports us as we practice together. Bring your own mat or use one of ours. Pay what you can; suggested donation is $5 per class. We hope to see you there!

RefugeeMeeting smallMany of you heard Rev. Stephen Cady speak about the refugee crisis in Eastern Europe and he expressed a concern that churches have been absent in the response. Stephen has been speaking with a missionary couple (see some of their story in the video below) and hosted a meeting to discuss how Asbury First might respond. 

On Sunday, February 19, more than 50 individuals convened in Fellowship Hall to brainstorm and explore ways the Asbury First community can make a meaningful, positive, and lasting difference for those impacted by the global refugee crisis. As a church community, Asbury First takes seriously its responsibility to better love and support those in our global family—including the refugee and the orphan—which was seen clearly on that Sunday afternoon. 

During the meeting, attendees with a passion for getting invovled in this effort came up with a number of ways we could make a difference. These ideas were recorded and the list will act as a jumping-off point for conversations that the Asbury First community will have in the days and months to come. A few of the proposed ideas included:

  • Create a database of refugee needs and local companies with a surplus, which may be matched up
  • Solidify our position on this issue with Scripture and reach out to other churches with which we can collaborate
  • Develop connections with churches in Europe and at the heart of this crisis
  • Invite local refugees to speak and share their testimonies in the hopes of spreading knowledge and understanding
  • Funnel support to Canada to strengthen their work in welcoming refugees
  • Develop ways to empower refugees to help themselves

If you're interested in being a part of this conversation moving forward, please contact Melody Guadagnino at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. and request that your email be added to the Refugee Crisis mailing list.


Charlie Greece Update 5 from Charlie Chastain on Vimeo.

RefugeeResponseWhile we had been very excited about a new possible use for 1010 East Ave and have been working behind the scenes for the last few months to try and make it a reality, we learned today that it is no longer a possibility. 

We apologize for any confusion that this might have caused as we scheduled and rescheduled this upcoming meeting.  Rest assured that the trustees and the rest of church leadership will continue to explore the best use for 1010 East Ave. and will update you as soon as we have a new recommendation.

Since many already had the meeting on their calendars, we would like to suggest that we meet to discuss another pressing topic for our congregation-the global refugee crisis

Many of you heard Stephen speak last Sunday about the refugee crisis in Eastern Europe and he expressed a concern that churches have been absent in the response. Stephen has been speaking with a missionary couple and would like to have a brainstorming session following the service on Sunday, February 19, to discuss how Asbury First might respond. This meeting will be the beginning of a much broader conversation. All are welcome.

This Lenten devotional offers a series of brief daily Scripture readings and reflections that we hope will enrich your personal faith life during this holy season. The readings for each day are selected from those assigned by the Revised Common Lectionary, and are accompanied by a quote or reflection from a wide array of our forefathers and foremothers in the faith. On Sundays, the reading will be accompanied by a morning and an evening prayer, which you might use each day throughout the week. We invite you to consider the common ground we share, not only with one another at Asbury First, but with Gods people throughout time and space.

daf960af 98a9 4003 af1d 4a2f1dd7e691The potential partner with whom we are in discussions about the use of Building 1010 needs more time to consider the exciting opportunity in front of them. We anticipate they will have a better sense of their intentions by the end of next week. In light of this development, we are rescheduling our meeting to Sunday, February 19 in Fellowship Hall following the 11 am service. We appreciate your patience and look forward to sharing further details on the 19th. The presentation will be broadcast and archived through the livestream on